Readers asked for a breakdown of Monday night’s RTM vote on the proposed appeal of the unmask ordinance to the RTM Legislative & Rules Committee.
More specifically, the vote was not on the proposed masking ordinance submitted by 20+ petitioners asking the RTM and the town not to follow state orders to require face masks for children in public and private schools.
Moderator Tom Byrne explained, “As a matter of procedure, your RTM moderator cannot accept a motion that would have the RTM take action in excess of its authority.”
Assistant town attorney Aamina Ahmad pointed to the Governor’s executive orders 9, 13A and 14A, saying they were binding and gave authority to Connecticut’s Dept of Education and Dept of Public Health to require masks in both private and public schools, though parents can request exemptions based on certain criteria.
Rather, the vote was on the legality of the item, and several people disagreed with Ms Ahmad, arguing that the executive orders and local requirements were unconstitutional.
Mr. Byrne explained that a yes vote would refer the legality of the item to the RTM’s Legislative & Rules committee.
No: Andrea Anthony, Katharine Ashworth, Joshua Brown, Ed Dadakis, Alanna Hynes, Brigitte Lee, Frederick Lee, Jaysen Medhurst, Elizabeth Sanders, Ryan Oca, Dan Quigley, Lihong Zhang
Yes: Dean C Goss, Judy Goss, Bill Lewis
Abstain: Carl Carlson
No: Mike Basham, Kate Lobalbo, Mary Ellen Markowitz, Eileen Toretta
Yes: Duncan Burke, Nancy Burke, Don Conway, Laura Gladstone, Jill Kelly, Michele Klosson, Wilma Nacinovich, Erica Walsh
Abstain: Aldo Pascarella
No: Louise Bavis, Martin Blanco, Judd Cohen, Thomas Conelias, Ed Lopez, Syl Pecora Sr, Steven Rubin, Allison Walsh
Abstain: Rosalind Nicastro
No: Javier Aleman, Paul Cappiali, Ronald Carosella, Andrea Casson, Liz Eckert, Robert McKnight, Maria Popp, Diego Sanchez, Sam Tamm, Donald Vitti, Lucy von Brachel, Bonnie Zeh
No: Edward Broadhurst, Nancy Cooper, Stephen Dolan, Lucy Krasnor, Hale McSharry, Paul Olmsted, Christopher Parker, Charles Parkhurst, Ashley Smith, Joan Thakor and Peter Van Duyne
Yes: Joseph Benoit, Allison “Icy” Frantz, Allison Rogers, Felix Rovelli, and Catherine Whitaker
Abstain: Danyal Ozizmir
No: Marilyn Cahn, Carol Ducret, Candace Garthwaite, Coline Jenkins, Gunnar Klintberg, Leander Krueger, Arline Lomazzo, Brian Maher, Janet McGuigan, Stephen Meskers, Jo Ann O’Hara, Barbara O’Neill, Victoria Quake, David Snyder, and Victoria Martin Young
No: Kimberly Morgan Blank, Ellen Brennan-Galvin, Mary G Nanette Burrows, Jill Cobbs, Alice Duff, Betsy Galindo, Scott Kalb, Doreen Pearson and Elizabeth Perry
Yes: Hilary Gunn, Elizabeth MacGillivray, Elizaeth “Wynn” McDaniel, Henry Orphys, Valerie Stauffer and Luke Szymczak
No: Hector Arzeno, Lisa Becker Edmundson, Peter Berg, Kip Burgweger, Irene Dietrich, Philip Dodson, Christine Edwards, Jennifer Freitag, Dana Gordon, Richard Margenot, Janet Lee McMahon, Linda Moshier, Cheryl Moss, Robert Moss, Jonathan Perloe, Caryn Rosenbaum, and Alison Soler
Yes: Jill Capalbo, Randy Caravella, Adele Caroll, Neil Caton, Carlton “Carl” Higbie, Kons Katsigiannakis, Andrew Oliver, Molly Saleeby
No: Phyllis Alexander, Claudia Carthaus, Barbara Darula, Melissa Evans, Betsy Frumin, Donna Gaudioso-Zeale, Anne Jones, Deborah Krautheim, Abbe Large, Brian Malin, Jonathan Shankman, Jane Weisbecker and Carol Zarrilli
Yes: Seth Bacon, Michael Brescia, Lauren O’Keefe, Brian Raney
No: Gerald Anderson, Jude Collins, Mareta Hamre, Katherine Hynes, Sara Kessler, John Mastracchio, Diana Singer, Louisa Stone, Sophie Veronis and Svetlona Wasserman
Yes: Allyson Cowinn, Brooks Harris, Ramya Hopley and Sheryl Sorbaro
No: Nancy Better, Victoria Bostock, Thomas Devaney, Susan Fahey, Tracy Freedman, Karen Giannuzzi, Margaret Heppelmann, Susan Khanna, Adam Leader, Dana Neuman, Richard Neuman, Greg Pauletti, Ralph Penny, Cathryn Fineman Steel, Ronald Strackbein, Gregory Zorthian
Yes: Kim Salib, Michael Spilo, Thomas West
No: Hajime Agresta, Thomas Agresta, Francia Alvarez, Craig Amundson, Glen Canner, Mary Flynn, Barbara Hindman, Mary Keller, Paula Legere Mickley, Aaron Leonard, Robert May, Abigail McCarthy, Jocelyn Riddle, Andrew Winston
Yes: Frederick Lorthioir and Jane Sulich
Abstain: Jeffrey Crumbine