Fassuliotis: John Cooper’s Fine Art of BOE Lawsuit Spin

Submitted by Karen Fassuliotis

John Cooper’s letter does more than criticize First Selectman Fred Camillo. It levels sweeping unsubstantiated accusations of “waste, fraud and abuse,” dismisses the lawsuit as frivolous, and spins the narrative to portray Camillo as seeking “absolute power and control” over Greenwich politics. Yet Cooper offers little to no support for those charges and leaves out facts central to understanding how this dispute began. Strong accusations may make for attention-grabbing rhetoric, but they are no substitute for an honest account of the record.

The dispute began after Board of Education member Karen Kowalski resigned in July 2024. The vacancy remained open for 94 days. On October 21, after the Board of Selectmen had scheduled a public meeting for the following day to fill the seat, four BOE members called an emergency meeting. Notice was filed just 42 minutes before it began. They voted to appoint Jennifer Behette. The next day, the Selectmen held their properly noticed meeting and appointed Paul Cappiali.

Connecticut’s Freedom of Information Commission later found that the October 21 meeting did not qualify as an emergency, that the BOE had not acted in good faith to comply with notice requirements, and that the action taken at the meeting was null and void. The Commission did not decide the separate question of the First Selectman’s authority. But Cooper says nothing about these findings. He simply calls the lawsuit frivolous, as though the state’s decision were irrelevant.

Camillo has explained that he sought a court ruling after BOE members challenged the Selectmen’s appointment and threatened legal action against the Town. That is a genuine dispute over who has the authority to fill a vacancy, not, by itself, evidence of a personal power grab. The First Selectman has a responsibility to protect the Town’s interests. Seeking judicial clarification when public officials disagree over their legal authority is a legitimate way to resolve that dispute.

Nor has Camillo refused to seek a resolution. On November 9, he met with Acting BOE Chair Sophie Koven and Cappiali. Koven described the conversation as productive, while making clear that no specific terms had been agreed and any proposal would require a public vote of the full board.

Cooper’s attack on Cappiali is even less connected to the issue. He lists Cappiali’s roles—from organizing the St. Roch fair to Harbormaster, BOE member and RTC chair—and attributes his public service to Camillo’s “tutelage.” The implication is that Cappiali is a political favorite. But Cooper offers no evidence of a favor or improper deal. Cappiali was appointed by the Selectmen and later elected to the BOE by Greenwich voters. Serving the community in several capacities is not evidence of political patronage. And, more importantly, Cappiali did not create the vacancy or call the October 21 meeting.

Cooper also points to Cappiali’s election and the November 3 results as evidence that voters rejected Camillo’s actions. But what does one have to do with the other? Cappiali’s election doesn’t change what happened in October 2024 or the commission’s findings. And voters weren’t being asked to decide whether that meeting was handled properly. This shouldn’t be about which party gets its way. Everyone should expect the same thing from public officials: follow the rules and the law, be open with the public, and take responsibility when things go wrong.

The cost of the BOE’s decisions is another part of the story Cooper leaves out. At a May 2026 budget meeting, officials identified nearly $497,000 in legal fees associated with the dispute, including Town expenses and BOE bills that had not yet been paid. More recently, the BET chair referred to legal bills exceeding $700,000. The BOE is also proposing another $500,000 for legal expenses in its 2027–28 budget. These expenses did not arise in a vacuum. Camillo sought a court ruling after BOE members challenged the Selectmen’s appointment and threatened legal action against the Town. That context matters. The BOE’s actions led to the FOI complaint and the commission’s subsequent findings. Rather than focusing exclusively on the cost of the Town’s effort to resolve the legal dispute, Cooper should also address the decisions that brought it about and the BOE’s continued expenditure of public funds in connection with the matter. And there is a further question worth asking: should taxpayers automatically bear the full cost of legal representation for board members whose actions were found by the commission to have violated FOI requirements, or should the question of personal responsibility for some of those expenses be examined?

Greenwich residents deserve more than Cooper’s selective version of events. We deserve the whole story: what happened, what the state commission found, what remains unresolved, and what taxpayers are being asked to pay. Cooper tells readers to “read the room.” Perhaps he should start by reading the record—and addressing the facts his letter leaves out. Rhetoric is easy. Accountability requires the truth.

Karen Fassuliotis is currently a magistrate in the small claims court system and a former Board of Estimate and Taxation member.